CHILDREN’S BOOKS

Two Picture Books That Set the Table for an Object Lesson

Sometimes a spoon is just a spoon.

By Joshua David Stein

Joshua David Stein’s children’s books include “Lunch From Home,” “What’s Cooking?” and “Solitary Animals.”

Published Nov. 22, 2024

Updated Nov. 25, 2024

 THE TABLE (Neal Porter/Holiday House, 56 pp., $19.99, ages 4 to 8), the wildly creative new picture book from Winsome Bingham and Wiley Blevins, illustrated by Jason Griffin. Bingham, whose first book, “Soul Food Sunday,” was a colorful evocation of a cookout, here turns to Appalachia, to which she immigrated from Jamaica when she was a child. Blevins, meanwhile, is an early reading specialist and serial children’s author who comes from a family of coal miners in West Virginia.

Bingham and Blevins put a lot on the table here. As the narrative, such as it is, traces the passing of a kitchen table from one family to another, the table becomes a stage on which various tableaus are mounted. (Griffin keeps our gaze fixed firmly on the table. No characters, save for a dog, are pictured.)

In the first family, of white Appalachian coal miners, peas need eating; a dress needs sewing; a book needs reading aloud, since Meemaw is illiterate; bills need paying. When Papa loses his job, enough of those bills aren’t paid that the family lose their home. They move into a smaller place: “We all fit, except the table.”

The exiled table “finds a new place to stand on the side of the road,” where soon it is claimed by another family. Black and seemingly less impoverished, they too play out their domestic life atop the table. Across its surface more memories are formed: crossword puzzles worked on, math homework done, biscuits eaten, beef stew slurped.

Editors’ Picks

As the table changes owners, so too does the storytelling. Hands that were white are now Black. Mamma becomes Momma. Papa becomes Daddy. Only the “I,” though differently voiced — and the hand-lettered, cutout text style — remain the same. This is as tidy a metaphor for commonality as you’ll find outside a stump speech.

In the gymnastic narrative switcheroo, one can smell the pipe smoke of William Faulkner, avant-garde bard of the South. In the grace said at the table in its second home, in the cadence of the second father’s speech, one can hear whispers of Albert Murray’s “South to a Very Old Place.” “Baby, I’ve been a carpenter all my life,” Daddy says. “This table’s seen a lot of things. Done been ’round for a long, long time.”

“The Table” is innovative, complex and touching. It’s full of clever parallels, poetic language and melancholic beauty. But other than where it’s shelved and how it’s marketed, it’s not a children’s book. That is, it’s not likely to appeal to young children, at least not the 4- to 8-year-olds who are supposedly its target demographic. The allusions, the presupposed knowledge, the abrupt shift in narrative viewpoint, the lack of pictured characters — all these conspire to keep the meaning and pleasures of the text out of reach for most little ones.

A children’s book needn’t be — and shouldn’t be — facile, with all the questions answered or, even worse, with none posed. It needn’t be slow; it should move, like a merry-go-round, but at a pace that allows a reader to hop on.

Books like “The Table” move so fast — beautiful and shimmering in the light of their own brilliance — that there’s nothing to do but to stand back and admire them from afar. One wishes it could learn from “The Spoon” that an object lives when it’s used, not when it’s kept in a drawer or on a shelf to be admired.

A version of this article appears in print on Nov. 24, 2024, Page 18 of the Sunday Book Review with the headline: Kitchen Table Issues. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper | Subscribe